I thank Prof Swaran Singh for drawing my attention to a randomised trial of traditional faith healing with chemotherapy versus traditional faith healing alone for patients with serious psychiatric disorders.[1] The study took place in a faith-based healing centre. Belief in spiritual origins for mental illness is common in many countries. A randomised trial was conducted to evaluate the additional benefits of pharmacotherapy for patients with a range of psychotic conditions. The outcome of the trial was based on the brief psychiatric rating scale. Patients in the intervention group had much better outcomes than patients in the control group over the first six weeks following randomisation. That is to say, adding chemotherapy to faith healing produced a marked improvement in outcome.
The interesting feature of this trial was that it combined modern medical treatment with traditional healing methods. Thus it is not a head-to-head of the two different approaches; rather it is a trial of both methods compared with traditional methods alone.
Although the study produces interesting findings, the traditional methods did not sit comfortably with the medical approach; for instance patients were often put in chains so that they could not escape or harm themselves or others. This invokes the deeper question about whether the two methods (allopathic and traditional) can really exist side-by-side on a routine basis. Many providers of psychiatric services would find it difficult to live with a situation in which patients for whom they felt responsible were also subjected to practices that they consider degrading, if not outright harmful. The question can be fairly asked as to whether medical practitioners in the study were endorsing or even colluding in these practices. I tackled the moral and epistemological Implications of trying to integrate enlightenment science and spiritual practices within the same system of care, in a recent news blog.[2] The above research paper seems to reinforce my opinion that integration of modern medicine and traditional practices is much more than simply a technical issue. While clinical trials such as the one cited above can produce useful information, they cannot, by themselves, resolve the deeper issues.
— Richard Lilford, CLAHRC WM Director
- Ofori-Atta A, Attafuah J, Jack H, et al. Joining Psychiatric Care and Faith Healing in a Prayer Camp in Ghana: Randomised trial. Br J Psychiatry. 2018; 212: 34-41.
- Lilford RJ. Traditional Healers and Mental Health. NIHR CLAHRC West Midlands News Blog. 12 January 2018.